Showing posts with label Parenting Plan. Show all posts
Showing posts with label Parenting Plan. Show all posts

Thursday, April 12, 2018

Shared Parenting and Relocation

In Washington State, when a parent wishes to relocate with children, the residential schedule designated in the Parenting Plan may have significant legal consequences for the impending move.  Do the parties have a traditional every other weekend schedule, where one parent is clearly the primary residential parent?  Or do the parties have a joint custody type of arrangement, often termed as a shared parenting plan or 50/50 residential time?  The type of Parenting Plan involved may influence whether a parent decides to pursue a move with the children or whether an agreement outside of Court can be had. 

For parents with an every other weekend schedule or something similar (i.e., there is a clearly defined primary residential parent), the burden will be on the non-moving parent to block the move.  When the primary residential parent under a PareNotice, once an Objection is made by the non-moving parent, a contested hearing will need to be held by the Court.  At the hearing, the moving parent has a significant, often insurmountable built-in advantage, over the non-moving parent.  This is called a "rebuttable presumption" that the move should be allowed.  To overcome the presumption, the objecting parent must demonstrate that detrimental effect of the relocation outweighs the benefit to the child and relocating parent through an assessment of 11 statutory factors under the CRA.  As a result, a tremendous, difficult burden is placed upon the non-moving parent to prove the harmful effects of the relocation, and as such, many primary residential parents are allowed to move with children, often to the heartbreak of an objecting, non-moving parent.
nting Plan wishes to move outside of the children’s school district, Notice is required which triggers application of Washington's Child Relocation Act (CRA). The CRA provides a detailed process for parents intended to move with children.  After

By contrast, for parents that have a substantially shared parenting plan or 50/50 residential time, the burden will be on the moving parent to obtain permission for the move.  In 2017, Division Two of the Washington Court of Appeals determined the CRA does not apply when the children’s residential time is designated equal or substantially equal in the Parenting Plan, and when the intended relocation would result in a change in this designation.  Since the CRA has been found NOT to apply in these circumstances, the moving parent must file a Petition for a Parenting Plan Modification in order to relocate with the children.  In doing so, the moving parent must establish, based upon a substantial change in circumstances, that "adequate cause" for the modification exists.  If the moving parent cannot establish "adequate cause", the petition will fail.  This is a high burden to prove, and may limit or otherwise influence a parent's decision about a prospective move with children.

For any parent who is considering Relocation, Objection to such a move, or a Parenting Plan Modification action, understanding the appropriate legal approach is essential.  Finding an experienced attorney who understands Relocation and Modification cases may be beneficial.

Family law litigation can be emotionally difficult and complex. Decisions made about each step of the litigation can affect you for many years. We have years of experience helping our clients through the difficulty of Relocation and Parenting Plan litigation and can help you through the process. Contact us today at (253) 838 – 3377 or email at office@bainslawfirm.com, to discuss about your situation.

Disclaimer: All materials provided on this website have been prepared by Bains Law Firm for general information purposes only and no representation is made as to their completeness or accuracy. Information on this website is not intended as legal advice, and may not be relied upon as such. Only an attorney who can review the unique facts of each case and apply them to the statutes, case law and court rules can provide legal advice. Nothing in this website shall be construed to create an attorney-client relationship.

Wednesday, February 28, 2018

Successful Co-Parenting


Relationship breakups, whether it be divorce, separation or committed intimate relationships, is confusing and stressful for all families, but particularly so for the families with children. It is often difficult for newly separated parents to determine what kind of long-term parenting arrangement will be best for the children once each parent has established their own household.
In family law cases involving children, the court's primary concern is with the best interests of the children. This should be your primary concern as well. Here are some tips that will help you and your former partner co-parent your children as you navigate the process of establishing separate households.

Minimize chaos and establish a routine
Recognize that children are used to their routine and environment, try your best to maintain the routine as you all adjust to living in two households. Establish a "new normal" that reflects the old normal as much as possible.
Every family is different and there is no perfect formula for determining the right visitation schedule for a given family. An experienced family law attorney can help you develop a fair, balanced plan that is both tailored to your kids' needs and legally realistic.

Be consistent
Whether you have an informal or court-ordered schedule for time with your children, be sure to take that time on a consistent basis. If you absolutely must miss an opportunity to spend time with your children, be sure to contact the other parent right away and establish a time to make up for the missed visit.
Parental consistency and stability for children are also critical concerns for family law judges and commissioners when making custody decisions. Failure to follow your schedule for visitation could be harmful to your case and is certainly not good for your children.

Shield your children from conflict
It's also important that both you and the other parent make every effort to shield your children from legal proceedings, and from parental conflict.
In general, without casting blame, stick with age appropriate explanations of why one parent is no longer living at home. It’s very important to soothe a child's fears and confusion about the changes in his or her life, but your kids don't need to know the details of their parents' adult relationship.
Absolutely avoid getting into an argument with the other parent in the presence of your children. Address any grievances you may have with the other parent directly, privately, and as calmly as possible.
A formal parenting plan with specific provisions governing exchanges of your children can help you minimize face-to-face contact if you and your spouse are simply unable to interact without hostility.
Counseling is also a beneficial way to help the children and the whole family get through this difficult time.

Communicate (cautiously) in writing
Email and text messages are convenient ways to communicate with your spouse about your goals, concerns, and upcoming plans for your kids. There are several easy to use Co-parenting apps that can help parents establish a written record and reduce hostility, confusion and miscommunication.
But, most importantly - think before you click "send." Don't write or publish anything that you would not want a judge to hear. This also applies to social media sites such as Facebook, Twitter and Instagram. Composing a long rant about your spouse's many flaws as a partner and parent might make you feel a little better in the short term, but your words are counterproductive to co-parenting.
If you’re unsure about how to best communicate with your spouse, the advice of an experienced family law attorney can provide you with a strategy for communicating with your spouse in a productive and effective manner.

Keep your focus on your kids
If the end of your relationship has been tough on you, just imagine how difficult it is for your kids. They're worried about you and they're worried about what is going to happen to them.
Check in with your kids to see how they're feeling. Talk to their teachers, coaches, and counselors, and work with them to make sure your kids aren't falling behind in school and other important activities. Try to be 100% engaged during your one-on-one time, even if you are feeling resentful or upset about the end of your relationship.
The benefits of continuing to be an involved parent no matter your relationship status, are intangible and invaluable to your children. Staying focused on your kids' needs not only strengthens your legal position, it also helps your children feel secure in an uncertain time.

Family Law litigation can be emotionally difficult and complex. Decisions made about each step of the litigation can affect you for many years. We have years of experience helping our clients through the difficulty of family law litigation and can help you through the process. Contact us today at (253) 838 – 3377 or email at office@bainslawfirm.com, to talk about your situation.



Disclaimer: All materials provided on this website have been prepared by Bains Law Firm for general information purposes only and no representation is made as to their completeness or accuracy. Information on this website is not intended as legal advice, and may not be relied upon as such. Only an attorney who can review the unique facts of each case and apply them to the statutes, case law and court rules can provide legal advice. Nothing in this website shall be construed to create an attorney-client relations

Monday, June 26, 2017

Use of Social Media in Family Law



June 23, 2017 - Bains Law Firm

Facebook, Instagram, Snapchat, Twitter, LinkedIn, Pinterest, Tumbler, Youtube, etc.:  These are just a handful of Social Media platforms from which communications can be, and often are, used in Court as evidence. In our increasingly digital age, it is quite common for Social Media communications to be used in Family Law cases, especially those that involve Protection Orders or Parenting issues.

Individuals who use Social Media freely post pictures, videos, comments, or status updates, often without considering the risks and dangers of current or future litigation. Even when a post is deleted from an account, it may be accessible somewhere else. Caution should be taken with every Social Media post or communication, even if it is believed to be private. Being aware of the audience is important because even a “blocked” person can access a post through a third party.  Or a person could be unknowingly "tagged" in an embarrassing photo which is used against them at a later time.  Even something such as a dating profile from Match.com, Tinder, eHarmony, etc., can be used as evidence in Court.

The point needs to be stressed:  A person does not need to be online "friends" with another person for a damaging Social Media post to end up in the Court record.

Generally, Social Media evidence is often admitted in Court unless it has been acquired by fraud or some other impermissible means, such as someone hacking into an account.  As a result, being mindful of what to put online and what not to post, is very important for individuals engaged in Family Law litigation.
A general rule of thumb is to act as if every post may become public and presented to the Court. Only use language and information that is presentable to a judge. Avoiding posting on Social Media at a time of extreme emotional upset, frustration or anger is generally prudent.

Deleting Social Media accounts is not necessary, but being attentive to what is posted is vital, especially when involved in ongoing litigation. Recently, the use of Social Media as evidence in Court has increased substantially.  According to a national survey of family law attorneys:

81% have seen increased use of evidence from social networking websites.
66% of the evidence used was found on Facebook.

And it's not just postings on Social Media.  That same national survey also found that 92% of attorneys had an increase in cases using evidence taken from smart phones in the past few years.  So if a person is in the middle of litigation, they should be careful as to every text, email or other communication that is sent to the opposing party.

Social Media posts, photos or other messages can be used for a variety of reasons in Court, such as to contradict statements made in Court or pre-trial disclosures. For example:



If a party claims not to have a substance abuse problem, but they have numerous postings of partying, bar hopping or worse.
Example: “Enjoying Happy Hour cause it’s Wednesday!”






Avoid statements or photos that may be intended for other reasons but also might demonstrate inappropriate parenting.
Example: "Family Vacation to the Beach", yet the driver is distracted and seatbelt is around the child's neck.






A claim of financial need can be easily undermined with photos of frivolous spending Example: "Love my New Boat!"







In Family Law cases, the above examples are merely a few of the countless ways that Social Media posts can be used to damage a party's legal position.

Family Law litigation can be emotionally difficult and complex. Decisions made about each step of the litigation can affect you for many years. We have years of experience helping our clients through the difficulty of family law litigation and can help you through the process. Contact us today at (253) 838 – 3377 or email at office@bainslawfirm.com, to talk about your situation.



Disclaimer: All materials provided on this website have been prepared by Bains Law Firm for general information purposes only and no representation is made as to their completeness or accuracy. Information on this website is not intended as legal advice, and may not be relied upon as such. Only an attorney who can review the unique facts of each case and apply them to the statutes, case law and court rules can provide legal advice. Nothing in this website shall be construed to create an attorney-client relations

Friday, May 19, 2017

Violations of Court Orders: Enforcement, Contempt, and Punitive Sanctions.


May 19, 2017 – Bains Law Firm

In Family Law, often a party does not comply with the Court's Order.  When that happens, what can be done?  In Washington there are a variety of legal remedies to compel enforcement, impose contempt, or otherwise punish a party for violations of a valid Court Order.

Contempt of Court for Child Support and Parenting Plan Violations:
Contempt is a serious remedy that is often used in the context of violations of a ChildSupport Order or a Parenting Plan.  Bringing a contempt motion should be carefully considered.  When a parent fails to pay child support (usually a repeat violation), pursuing contempt might be appropriate.  For parenting plans, when a parent withholds the child,  refuses to allow visitation, does not allow access to the child, or violates any number of provisions in the plan, contempt may be appropriate.  Since contempt is a serious matter, it is often prudent to send a noncompliance letter (or some other form of notice), prior to seeking contempt sanctions.  This will provide the offending party an opportunity to cure or otherwise resolve the situation short of court action. 

(1)  "Contempt of court" means intentional:

(a) Disorderly, contemptuous, or insolent behavior toward the judge while holding the court, tending to impair its authority, or to interrupt the due course of a trial or other judicial proceedings;

(b) Disobedience of any lawful judgment, decree, order, or process of the court;

(c) Refusal as a witness to appear, be sworn, or, without lawful authority, to answer a question

·         Consequences of Child Support not being paid:
o    If a parent is found in contempt, in addition to paying upon the support that is owed, the parent may liable for monetary sanctions (including, but not limited to costs and attorney fees), liens assessed against property/accounts or even seized, wages garnished, licenses suspended, and even, in the most extreme situations, the parent is sent to jail.

·         Consequences of Parenting Plan being violated:
o    If a parent is found in contempt, remedies can include make up visitation, monetary sanctions (including, but not limited to costs and attorney fees), and again, in the most extreme cases, even jail time.  Furthermore, if a parent has been found to be in contempt for violating residential provisions twice in a 3 year time period, the parenting plan may be modified. 

Restraining Order: This is a civil order, generally filed in the context of an existing family law case, such as a pending dissolution or child custody case. This type of order is different from a Domestic Violence Protection Order since it may deal with property, parenting plan, spousal or child support, as well as domestic violence issues.  
·         Consequences of Violation of Order:
o    Contempt and/or monetary sanctions, including, but not limited to costs and attorney fees, amendment of the order violated to include harsher restrictions or restraints, and even possible criminal charges. 

Domestic ViolenceProtection Order: This is a civil order from the Court issued at the request of a person claiming to be the victim of domestic violence.
·         Consequences of Violation of Order:
o    Possible criminal charges or contempt.  If criminal charges are pursued, this may include Class C felony if there is an assault or reckless endangerment, otherwise a Gross Misdemeanor.

Sexual Assault Protection Order: This is a often a civil order from the Court (but can also be done in the context of a criminal action).
·         Consequences of Violation of Order:
o    Possible criminal charges or contempt.  If criminal charges are pursued, Class C felony if there is an assault or reckless endangerment, otherwise a Gross Misdemeanor.

Anti-Harassment Order: This is a civil order issued for a person claiming any type of harassment and when a person does not qualify for a Domestic Violence Protection Order. These orders are commonly filed in disputes that don’t involve a domestic relationship.
·         Consequences of Violation of Order:
o    Possible criminal charges or contempt.  If criminal charges are pursued, may likely involve a Gross Misdemeanor.

Family law litigation can be emotionally difficult and complex. Decisions made about each step of the litigation can affect you for many years. We have years of experience helping our clients through the difficulty of enforcing violations of court order, and can help you through the process. Contact us today at (253) 838 – 3377 or email at office@bainslawfirm.com to talk about your case.

Disclaimer: All materials provided on this website have been prepared by Bains LawFirm for general information purposes only and no representation is made as to their completeness or accuracy. Information on this website is not intended as legal advice, and may not be relied upon as such. Only an attorney who can review the unique facts of each case and apply them to the statutes, case law and court rules can provide legal advice. Nothing in this website shall be construed to create an attorney-client relationship.


Saturday, April 15, 2017

Washington State Family Law & Divorce: Non-Parental (Third Party) Custody; Grandparents Rights

April 15, 2017 - Bains Law Firm 


Non-parental custody actions are brought when third parties (people other than the actual parents)  seek custody of minor children where either both parents are unfit, or where the children have been voluntarily placed with a third party by the parents. 

Before a non-parental custody case can proceed, a party seeking nonparental custody is required to establish "adequate cause" for the petition.  This is often referred to as a "threshold requirement".  On January 19, 2017, the Washington State Supreme Court set forth that before a trial on the merits of a non-parental custody petition, a litigant must satisfy the threshold requirement of "adequate cause" by showing that the biological parent is either unfit or that placing the child in the parent's custody would result in actual detriment to the growth and development.  If the court finds that there is not adequate cause to proceed with the case, the case will be dismissed. If the court finds that there is adequate cause, temporary orders may be entered, a parenting investigation may occur and the case will proceed to trial if it is not resolved by way of settlement. 

A common misperception is that Washington State allows for grandparent's rights or third party visitation.  However, there is no right to grandparent or third party visitation as the law has been interpreted, and as such, grandparents or other third parties are given the option of seeking custody or nothing at all.

Non-parental custody cases are usually an emergent action for children in danger. Often in the case of grandparents, a difficult practical and emotional balance must be struck.  Grandparents  do not want to act as "parents" again, but feel that they have to step in to help their grandchildren.  If this is the situation, it is important to know that there is a statute that permits you to save your grandchildren.  Since there is no such thing as grandparent or third party visitation in Washington State, and the fact that there is an adequate cause/threshold requirement that must be met in order for the litigation to proceed forward, it is very important to prepare the case thoroughly before filing a petition for non-parental custody.   

Family law litigation, including non-parental custody actions, can be emotionally difficult and complex. Decisions made about each step of the litigation can affect you for many years. We have years of experience helping our clients through the difficulty of non-parental custody actions and can help you through the process. Contact us today at (253) 838 – 3377 or email at office@bainslawfirm.com, to talk about your divorce.





Disclaimer: All materials provided on this website have been prepared by Bains Law Firm for general information purposes only and no representation is made as to their completeness or accuracy. Information on this website is not intended as legal advice, and may not be relied upon as such. Only an attorney who can review the unique facts of each case and apply them to the statutes, case law and court rules can provide legal advice. Nothing in this website shall be construed to create an attorney-client relationship.  

Wednesday, April 12, 2017

Washington State Family Law & Divorce: Parenting Plan--Who Speaks for the Child?

April 12, 2017 – Bains Law Firm

In contested family law cases with children, emotions can run high and allegations plentiful if child custody is an issue.  When both parents are seeking primary residential placement, or "custody" of the children, there is often no shortage of harmful and hurtful allegations.  Serving the best interests of the children becomes excruciatingly difficult for the Court to resolve when the parents are focused upon tearing each other down.  As such, when parenting abilities are an issue, the Court will often use a neutral third party to investigate the children's circumstances, make parenting recommendations, and sometimes even advocate on behalf of the child. Although the Court has the power to interview the children directly, such occurrences are quite rare.  Every county in Washington state follows their own procedures to assist the Court in determining the children's best interests in difficult contested parenting matters. 

For example, for parenting plan issues arising in King County, there are a variety of tools for a Court Commissioner or Judge to use to look into the children's actual circumstances.  The Court may appoint a Guardian ad Litem, private parenting evaluator, or even use lower cost options, such as Family Court Services or CASA (Court Appointed Special Advocates).  Any of these methods can provide the Court with very useful information regarding the children.

In Pierce County, the Court most often relies upon a Guardian ad Litem to be appointed from a court-approved registry.  When a Court Commissioner or Judge enters an Order authorizing the use of a Guardian ad Litem, three names will be generated from the registry.  Each parent will have the opportunity to strike one of the names, and the one name remaining will be appointed as the Guardian ad Litem.

The professional, whether it be a Guardian ad Litem, parenting evaluator, or other type of parenting investigator, will most often look at the Court filings, interview the parents, children and other relevant witnesses, as well as review other pertinent evidence to assist in generating a report and recommendations to serve the best interests of the children.  While the Court is not bound to follow any such recommendations, oftentimes the input of such a professional is very helpful to the Court's determination of custody and parenting issues. 

The statute below grants the Court its authority to interview the children and/or appoint a professional to look into the children's circumstances.


Parenting plans—Interview with child by court—Advice of professional personnel.

The court may interview the child in chambers to ascertain the child's wishes as to the child's residential schedule in a proceeding for dissolution of marriage or domestic partnership, legal separation, or declaration of invalidity. The court may permit counsel to be present at the interview. The court shall cause a record of the interview to be made and to be made part of the record in the case.

The court may seek the advice of professional personnel whether or not they are employed on a regular basis by the court. The advice given shall be in writing and shall be made available by the court to counsel upon request. Counsel may call for cross-examination any professional personnel consulted by the court.


Family law litigation, particularly contested child custody matters, can be emotionally difficult and complex. Decisions made about each step of the litigation can affect you for many years. We have decades of experience helping our clients through the difficulty of family law cases, including contested parenting cases and can help you through the process. Contact us today at (253) 838 – 3377 or email at office@bainslawfirm.com, to talk about your case.




Disclaimer: All materials provided on this website have been prepared by Bains Law Firm for general information purposes only and no representation is made as to their completeness or accuracy. Information on this website is not intended as legal advice, and may not be relied upon as such. Only an attorney who can review the unique facts of each case and apply them to the statutes, case law and court rules can provide legal advice. Nothing in this website shall be construed to create an attorney-client relationship.


Tuesday, April 4, 2017

Washington State Family Law & Divorce: Post-Secondary Educational Support

April 4, 2017 – Bains Law Firm

Bains Law Firm
In Washington State, postsecondary educational support can be ordered to require parents to pay for college for their children.  In general, child support obligations end when a child turns eighteen or graduates from high school (whichever occurs later), unless postsecondary educational support is awarded.

When determining whether postsecondary support is required of the parents, the first thing to do is to review the final child support order.  If the Court has already established a postsecondary educational support obligation, further Court action is probably unlikely.  The parents and the child will have to abide by the postsecondary educational support provision that has been established in the final child support order. 

However, when the final child support order sets forth that postsecondary educational support is "reserved" (not addressed), then a petition to modify child support will need to be filed.  Reserving postsecondary educational support for a later determination is quite common, unless the child is already in high school at the time the final child support order is entered.  Either parent can file a petition to modify the final child support order but it must be done before the child turns eighteen or is no longer enrolled in high school (whichever occurs later).

To qualify for postsecondary support, the adult dependent child must meet certain statutory criteria, such as being enrolled in an accredited academic school and maintain good academic standing. A parent who is obligated to pay for the postsecondary support has the right to all academic records, including grades. In addition, postsecondary support can be suspended if the student does not maintain these requirements or after the child’s twenty-third birthday (unless special circumstances exist).  

When the Court is determining an award of postsecondary educational support, it considers the factors in RCW 26.19.090 (2), such as reliance of the child on the parents for the reasonable necessities of life. Other considerations include the age of the child, the child’s needs, the expectations of the parties, the child’s prospects, desires, aptitudes, abilities, or disabilities, as well as many other factors listed below.

Standards for postsecondary educational support awards.

 (2) When considering whether to order support for postsecondary educational expenses, the court shall determine whether the child is in fact dependent and is relying upon the parents for the reasonable necessities of life. The court shall exercise its discretion when determining whether and for how long to award postsecondary educational support based upon consideration of factors that include but are not limited to the following: Age of the child; the child's needs; the expectations of the parties for their children when the parents were together; the child's prospects, desires, aptitudes, abilities or disabilities; the nature of the postsecondary education sought; and the parents' level of education, standard of living, and current and future resources. Also to be considered are the amount and type of support that the child would have been afforded if the parents had stayed together.

Family law litigation can be emotionally difficult and complex. Decisions made about each step of the litigation can affect you for many years. We have decades of experience helping our clients through the difficulty of family law cases, including child support modifications and establishment of post secondary educational support obligations, and can help you through the process. Contact us today at (253) 838 – 3377 or email at office@bainslawfirm.com, to talk about your case.







Disclaimer: All materials provided on this website have been prepared by Bains Law Firm for general information purposes only and no representation is made as to their completeness or accuracy. Information on this website is not intended as legal advice, and may not be relied upon as such. Only an attorney who can review the unique facts of each case and apply them to the statutes, case law and court rules can provide legal advice. Nothing in this website shall be construed to create an attorney-client relationship.

Monday, March 27, 2017

Washington State Family Law & Divorce: Child Support Modification and Adjustment

March 27, 2017 – Bains Law Firm

Bains Law Firm
In Washington, provisions in "final" child support orders can be modified or adjusted.  The same is true for "final" parenting plans.  Such changes, however, cannot be made in final orders regarding most property awards or debt allocations entered in divorce or legal separation matters.  The following discusses modification and adjustment of final child support orders.

There are two ways for most parents to change a final child support order, either by a Petition to Modify Child Support, or a Motion for Adjustment of Child Support.

A parent can file a Petition to Modify a final child support order at any time upon a showing of substantially changed circumstances. However, a substantial change in circumstances cannot be a voluntary change by itself, such as voluntary unemployment or voluntary underemployment.

Alternatively, a Petition to Modify a final child support order can be filed without showing of a substantially changed circumstance, if one year has passed since the final order was entered, and if one of the following requirements is present:
(1)   If the order in practice works a severe economic hardship on either party of the child;
(2)   If a party requests an adjustment in an order for child support which was based on guidelines which determined the amount of support according to the child’s age, and the child is no longer in the age category on which the current support amount was based;
(3)   If a child is still in high school, upon a finding that there is a need to extend support beyond the eighteenth birthday to complete high school; or
(4)   To add an automatic adjustment of support provision consistent with RCW 26.09.100.

A parent can also file a Motion for Adjustment of child support after 24 months have passed from the date of the entry of the support order (or the last adjustment or modification, whichever is later), without showing a substantial change in circumstances, if one of the following has occurred:
(1)   Changes in the income of the parents; or
(2)   Changes in the economic table or standards in chapter 26.19 RCW.

Deciding which avenue to pursue, filing a Petition to Modify Child Support or filing a Motion for Adjustment of Child Support, requires detailed factual and legal analysis and should be undertaken upon consultation with competent family law counsel well versed in child support laws. 

Family law litigation can be emotionally difficult and complex. Decisions made about each step of the litigation can affect you for many years. We have decades of experience helping our clients through the difficulty of family law and child support actions and can help you through the process. Contact us today at (253) 838 – 3377 or email at office@bainslawfirm.com, to talk about your case.






Disclaimer: All materials provided on this website have been prepared by Bains Law Firm for general information purposes only and no representation is made as to their completeness or accuracy. Information on this website is not intended as legal advice, and may not be relied upon as such. Only an attorney who can review the unique facts of each case and apply them to the statutes, case law and court rules can provide legal advice. Nothing in this website shall be construed to create an attorney-client relationship.

Monday, March 20, 2017

Washington State Family Law & Divorce: Legal Separation

March 20, 2017 – Bains Law Firm

Bains Law Firm
In Washington State, married couples can file for a legal separation or they can file for a divorce (dissolution of marriage). The process for filing either for a legal separation or divorce is similar, but the legal ramifications are different.

A person may choose to file for legal separation instead of divorce for many different reasons, such as religious beliefs, insurance entitlements, military benefits, immigration status, or simply because the spouses desire not to get a divorce. In these types of situations, legal separation may be a more appropriate choice for the parties.  

To begin the process of legal separation, one party must file a petition to the Court, similar to a divorce petition. Once the legal separation process has started, either party can seek relief from the Court regarding issues of parenting, such as child support or parenting plans; or property, such as division of assets and allocation of debts. The Court can also address issues of restraining orders and spousal maintenance.  

A major difference between legal separation and divorce is the 90-day waiting period. Legal separation does not have a 90-day waiting period; the matter can be finalized quickly. By contrast, the soonest a final divorce order can be entered is after the expiration of the 90-day waiting period.  

Another difference is even after the legal separation is finalized, the parties are still married. As long as and until a final divorce order is entered, neither of the parties will be able to get remarried.

Lastly, when a legal separation order is entered instead of a divorce order, one spouse may be able to stay on the current health insurance of the other spouse, or may receive military benefits from their servicemember spouse.

Converting a legal separation to a divorce:

After the Court has entered a final legal separation order, either party can move to convert it to a final divorce order. In order to convert, a motion must be made to the Court after six months has passed since the final legal separation order has been entered.  


Family law litigation can be emotionally difficult and complex. Decisions made about each step of the litigation can affect you for many years. We have years of experience helping our clients through the difficulty of family law cases including legal separation and divorce, and can help you through the process. Contact us today at (253) 838 – 3377 or email at office@bainslawfirm.com, to talk about your case.








Disclaimer: All materials provided on this website have been prepared by Bains Law Firm for general information purposes only and no representation is made as to their completeness or accuracy. Information on this website is not intended as legal advice, and may not be relied upon as such. Only an attorney who can review the unique facts of each case and apply them to the statutes, case law and court rules can provide legal advice. Nothing in this website shall be construed to create an attorney-client relationship.

Wednesday, March 15, 2017

Washington State Family Law & Divorce: Parenting Plan Modification

March 15, 2017 – Bains Law Firm

Bains Law Firm
In Washington, "final" parenting plans are modifiable (as are final orders of child support).  This is unlike final orders regarding most property awards or debt allocations.  The following discusses modification of parenting plans. 

In order to modify a parenting plan, a parent must file a petition for modification to initiate the case.  Next, either party can bring the matter on for an adequate cause determination.  This is often called the "threshold requirement" because if a petition fails to establish that adequate cause exists, the case will be dismissed.  In an adequate cause hearing, the court looks at the facts alleged by the moving party, which if true, would be sufficient grounds for a modification action to go forward.  If the court finds that the adequate cause requirement has been satisfied, the case can proceed to further hearing and/or trial. 

Once adequate cause has been determined, the parties can also move for temporary orders.  (Note: A party may schedule a motion for temporary orders to be heard at the same time as the adequate cause hearing).  Absent a clear emergency, a court will not enter temporary orders in a parenting plan modification action until the threshold, or adequate cause, has been met. 

Under the modification statute, there are a variety of grounds for a parent to modify a parenting plan, generally grouped into "minor" and "major" modification actions.  Key portions of the relevant modification statute is below.

Minor Modification

The court may order adjustments to the residential aspects of a parenting plan upon a showing of a substantial change in circumstances of either parent or of the child … if the proposed modification is only a minor modification in the residential schedule that does not change the residence the child is scheduled to reside in the majority of the time and:

(a)        Does not exceed twenty-four full days in a calendar year; or

(b)        Is based on a change of residence of the parent with whom the child does not reside the majority of the time or an involuntary change in work schedule by a parent which makes the residential schedule in the parenting plan impractical to follow; or

(c)        Does not result in a schedule that exceeds ninety overnights per year in total, if the court finds that, at the time the petition for modification is filed, the decree of dissolution or parenting plan does not provide reasonable time with the parent with whom the child does not reside a majority of the time, and further, the court finds that it is in the best interests of the child to increase residential time with the parent in excess of the residential time period in (a) of this subsection.

Major Modification

RCW 26.09.260 (1)
….court shall not modify a prior custody decree or a parenting plan unless it finds, upon the basis of facts that have arisen since the prior decree or plan or that were unknown to the court at the time of the prior decree or plan, that a substantial change has occurred in the circumstances of the child or the nonmoving party and that the modification is in the best interest of the child and is necessary to serve the best interests of the child. The effect of a parent's military duties potentially impacting parenting functions shall not, by itself, be a substantial change of circumstances justifying a permanent modification of a prior decree or plan.

RCW 26.09.260 (2)
In applying these standards, the court shall retain the residential schedule established by the decree or parenting plan unless:

(a)        The parents agree to the modification;

(b)        The child has been integrated into the family of the petitioner with the consent of the other parent in substantial deviation from the parenting plan;

(c)        The child's present environment is detrimental to the child's physical, mental, or emotional health and the harm likely to be caused by a change of environment is outweighed by the advantage of a change to the child; or

(d)        The court has found the nonmoving parent in contempt of court at least twice within three years because the parent failed to comply with the residential time provisions in the court-ordered parenting plan, or the parent has been convicted of custodial interference in the first or second degree.

Due to the requirement of adequate cause, the initial petition and supporting pleadings need to be drafted very carefully to maximize the petitioning parent's opportunities for success.  Additionally, the statute also provides that if the court finds a modification action has been brought in bad faith, the court shall assess attorney’s fees and court costs against the moving party.  As a result, it is very important for parents to have competent family law counsel when making decisions regarding parenting plan modifications. 

Family law litigation can be emotionally difficult and complex. Decisions made about each step of the litigation can affect you for many years. We have years of experience helping our clients through the difficulty of family law and modification actions and can help you through the process. Contact us today at (253) 838 – 3377 or email at office@bainslawfirm.com, to talk about your case.









Disclaimer: All materials provided on this website have been prepared by Bains Law Firm for general information purposes only and no representation is made as to their completeness or accuracy. Information on this website is not intended as legal advice, and may not be relied upon as such. Only an attorney who can review the unique facts of each case and apply them to the statutes, case law and court rules can provide legal advice. Nothing in this website shall be construed to create an attorney-client relationship.